Nearly five decades after the tragic events that unfolded in Guyana, the nation is considering revisiting its somber past. The United States' Reverend Jim Jones and over 900 of his followers perished in the remote interior of this South American nation, marking one of the most significant acts of mass suicide in modern history. A government-supported tour company is now proposing to open the former commune, now hidden by lush vegetation, to tourists, a move that has reignited old wounds. Critics argue that such a venture would show disrespect to the victims and unearth a distressing chapter of history.
Jordan Vilchez, who was relocated to the Peoples Temple commune at the age of 14 after growing up in California, shared her ambivalent feelings about the proposed tour with The Associated Press in a phone call from the United States. She was in the capital of Guyana on the day Jones commanded hundreds of his followers to consume a poisoned, grape-flavored beverage, which was administered to the children first.
Among the casualties were her two sisters and two nephews. "I narrowly escaped death by a single day," she reflected. Vilchez, now 67, stated that Guyana has the right to capitalize on any initiatives related to Jonestown. However, she also expressed that "any situation where individuals were coerced into their demise should be approached with reverence." She hopes that the tour operator will provide historical context and explain the reasons why so many people traveled to Guyana with the belief that they were seeking a better life.
The tour is set to transport visitors to the remote village of Port Kaituma, nestled within the verdant jungles of northern Guyana. Accessible only by boat, helicopter, or plane, as rivers serve as the primary means of traversing Guyana's interior, the journey to the abandoned commune and former agricultural settlement is an additional six miles along a rough, overgrown dirt path. Neville Bissember, a law professor at the University of Guyana, has questioned the proposed tour, describing it as a "macabre and peculiar" concept in a letter that was recently published. "What aspect of Guyana's natural beauty and cultural heritage is represented in a location where mass suicide and other atrocities and human rights abuses were inflicted upon a group of American citizens, who had no connection to Guyana or its people?" he wrote.
Despite ongoing criticism, the tour has garnered strong support from the government's Tourism Authority and Guyana's Tourism and Hospitality Association. Tourism Minister Oneidge Walrond informed the AP that the government is backing the initiative at Jonestown but is cognizant of "some level of resistance" from certain segments of society. She mentioned that the government has already assisted in clearing the area "to ensure that a superior product can be marketed," and added that the tour might require approval from the Cabinet. "It certainly has my backing," she stated. "It is feasible. After all, we have witnessed how Rwanda has managed that terrible tragedy as a precedent."
Rose Sewcharran, the director of Wonderlust Adventures, the private tour operator planning to take visitors to Jonestown, expressed that she is encouraged by the support. "We believe it is high time," she said. "This occurs globally. We have numerous examples of dark, macabre tourism around the world, including Auschwitz and the Holocaust museum."
The mass suicide-murder in November 1978 was synonymous with Guyana for many years until vast reserves of oil and gas were discovered off the country's coast nearly a decade ago, transforming it into one of the world's largest offshore oil producers. New roads, schools, and hotels are being constructed across the capital, Georgetown, and beyond, and a nation that rarely saw tourists is now looking to attract more visitors. An obvious draw is Jonestown, argued Astill Paul, the co-pilot of a twin-engine plane that transported U.S. Representative Leo J. Ryan of California and a U.S. news crew to a village near the commune a day before the hundreds of deaths on November 18, 1978. He witnessed gunmen fatally shoot Ryan and four others as they attempted to board the plane on November 18 to return to the capital.
Paul told the AP that he believes the former commune should be developed as a heritage site. "I sat on the tourism board years ago and suggested we do this, but the minister at the time dismissed the idea because the government wanted nothing to do with macabre tourism," he recalled. Until recently, successive governments have avoided Jonestown, arguing that the country's image was severely damaged by the mass murder-suicide, even though only a few Indigenous individuals perished. The vast majority of victims were Americans like Vilchez who traveled to Guyana to follow Jones. Many endured beatings, forced labor, imprisonment, and rehearsals for mass suicide.
Those in favor of a tour include Gerry Gouveia, a pilot who also flew during the time Jonestown was active. "The area should be reconstructed solely for tourists to gain a firsthand understanding of its layout and the events that transpired," he said. "We should reconstruct Jim Jones's home, the main pavilion, and other structures that were present there." Today, all that remains are fragments of a cassava mill, parts of the main pavilion, and a rusted tractor that once pulled a flatbed trailer to transport temple members to the Port Kaituma airfield.
An Offering to the Land
Until now, most visitors to Jonestown have been journalists and family members of the deceased. Organizing an expedition independently is a daunting task: the area is far from the capital and difficult to access, and some consider the closest populated settlement to be perilous. "It's still a very, very, very rugged area," said Fielding McGehee, co-director of The Jonestown Institute, a non-profit organization.
"I don't see how this is going to be an economically viable project because of the substantial funds it would require to transform it into a viable place to visit." McGehee warned against relying on supposed witnesses who will be part of the tour. He said that the memories and stories that have been passed down through generations might not be accurate. "It's almost like a game of telephone," he said. "It does not assist anyone in understanding what happened in Jonestown."
He recalled how one survivor had proposed a personal project to develop the abandoned site, but those from the temple community questioned, 'Why do you want to do that?' McGehee noted that dark tourism is popular, and that visiting Jonestown means tourists could claim they visited a place where over 900 people died on the same day. "It's the prurient interest in tragedy," he said.
If the tour eventually commences, not everything will be visible to tourists. When Vilchez returned to Guyana in 2018 for the first time since the mass suicide-murder, she made an offering to the land upon her arrival in Jonestown. Among the items she buried in the abandoned commune where her sisters and nephews perished were strands of hair from her mother and father, who did not go to Jonestown. "It just felt like a gesture that honored the people that died," she said.
The Dow Jones Industrial Average, a revered market bellwether, has stumbled into its longest losing streak since Jimmy Carter's presidency, a bygone era of disco, flared jeans, and economic malaise. Like a once-mighty boxer now reeling from a flurry of blows, the index fell by 267 points, or 0.6%, on Tuesday, marking the ninth consecutive day of decline.
This streak, a throwback to February 1978, has etched itself into the annals of market history, yet the downturn has been relatively mild, with the Dow only losing 3% over the previous eight trading sessions—a mere blip in the grand scheme of the market's ebbs and flows.
While the Dow has stumbled, other indices have strutted forward, unfazed. The Nasdaq, buoyed by the surge in Big Tech and artificial intelligence, has remained robust, although it too closed lower by approximately 0.32% on Tuesday. The S&P 500, a more diverse basket of stocks, also saw a decline, ending the day down by about 0.39%. It's as if the market is a multifaceted creature, with some parts thriving while others falter.
Keith Lerner, co-chief investment officer and chief market strategist at Truist Advisory Services, remarked on this peculiar situation, noting, "It's a bit unusual. Capital continues to flow into technology stocks. That's the prevailing narrative in this market: AI and technology." Indeed, the allure of cutting-edge tech and the promise of AI-driven innovation have captivated investors, drawing their gaze away from the Dow's struggles.
A significant contributor to the Dow's recent losses has been UnitedHealthcare Group. The insurance giant, a heavyweight in the index, has seen its value diminish by 18% this month. This downturn began following the tragic shooting of UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson, a shocking event that sent ripples of uncertainty through the market. The stock continued to decline on Monday after President-elect Donald Trump pledged to "eliminate" drug-industry intermediaries, a move that could upend the healthcare landscape and leave investors questioning the future of this sector.
The Dow's losing streak precedes the Federal Reserve's interest rate decision on Wednesday, a momentous event that can send markets into a tizzy. Market participants, like spectators at a high-stakes game, widely anticipate a quarter-point rate cut by the Fed, a move that could inject some life into the economy and ease borrowing costs. However, officials might also indicate a slowdown in the pace of reductions in 2025, a subtle signal that could temper investors' enthusiasm.
Despite these recent setbacks, the blue-chip index has still gained 16% year-to-date, a testament to its resilience and the market's overall optimism. Moreover, the Dow is approximately 1,500 points (3.5%) above its level on Election Day. The markets initially rallied post-election, as investors breathed a sigh of relief that the election was concluded without recounts or legal battles. There has also been considerable excitement surrounding Trump's pledges to reduce bureaucratic hurdles and taxes, a cocktail of promises that has fueled investor optimism.
Lerner further elaborated on the post-election sentiment, saying, "Post-election, investors focused solely on the positive aspects of Trump's policy. Next year, they will have to consider both the positive and negative implications." This statement alludes to the apprehensions about Trump's threats to increase tariff rates and initiate mass deportations, actions that could introduce new headwinds for the market.
According to FactSet data, there has not been a losing streak of 10 days or more since an 11-day decline in 1974. Anthony Saglimbene, chief market strategist at Ameriprise, does not view the Dow's recent losing streak as an omen of impending difficulties. Instead, he suggests that the recent downturn represents some profit-taking following significant gains in recent weeks. There has also been a "slight recalibration of expectations regarding the risks and opportunities associated with the incoming Trump administration next year," Saglimbene said, "and whether a Trump 2.0 policy agenda can stimulate the kind of growth that is currently being factored into stock prices."
In the grand tapestry of market history, the Dow's current dip may well be a fleeting folly, a momentary hiccup in an otherwise strong year. Or perhaps it's a harbinger of fractures to come, a sign that the market's foundation is not as solid as it seems. Only time will tell if this streak is a mere blip or a crack that will widen and deepen, sending shockwaves through the financial world.
For now, investors watch and wait, their eyes darting between the flickering numbers on their screens and the shifting sands of economic and political landscapes. They know that the market, like a wild beast, can be unpredictable and unforgiving. And so, they tread cautiously, ever mindful of the risks and rewards that lie ahead.
The Dow's journey is a winding road, filled with twists and turns, ups and downs. It's a road that has been traveled by generations of investors, each with their own hopes and fears, dreams and nightmares. And as the Dow stumbles and stammers its way forward, it carries with it the weight of those who have come before and the hopes of those who will follow.
In the end, the Dow is more than just a collection of numbers and percentages. It's a mirror, reflecting the hopes and fears of a nation, the ebb and flow of an economy, the triumphs and tribulations of a people. And as it continues on its journey, it will undoubtedly face more challenges, more setbacks, more moments of triumph and despair. But through it all, it remains a beacon, a symbol of the enduring spirit of capitalism and the relentless pursuit of growth and prosperity.
By John Smith/Dec 12, 2024
By Olivia Reed/Dec 12, 2024
By Michael Brown/Dec 12, 2024
By Amanda Phillips/Dec 12, 2024
By Lily Simpson/Dec 12, 2024
By Benjamin Evans/Dec 12, 2024
By Emma Thompson/Dec 12, 2024
By Michael Brown/Dec 12, 2024
By Thomas Roberts/Dec 12, 2024
By Elizabeth Taylor/Dec 12, 2024
By Michael Brown/Dec 2, 2024
By Sarah Davis/Dec 2, 2024
By George Bailey/Dec 2, 2024
By Joshua Howard/Dec 2, 2024
By James Moore/Dec 2, 2024
By Victoria Gonzalez/Dec 2, 2024
By Emily Johnson/Dec 2, 2024
By Daniel Scott/Dec 2, 2024
By Emma Thompson/Dec 2, 2024
By Benjamin Evans/Dec 2, 2024